A support manager has two questions about a finalist. Can she recognize when a customer needs an urgent escalation? Can she use the company's approved writing tools to explain the next step clearly? Both skills matter on the job. They call for different instructions in the interview.
Christin Marshall, a senior talent acquisition specialist at Babylist, told Talent Signal News what she wants to learn in a live work session. “Can they still freely think and make things make sense and come up with a plan on their own?” That question belongs in the planning meeting, while the team can still decide which part of the work it wants to see unaided.
Give candidates a rule for each exercise before they start. Allow the tools people use at work when the exercise measures what they can accomplish with those tools. Reserve an unaided step for a specific ability the person will need to exercise independently. In Criteria’s 2026 survey of job seekers, 34% of job seekers said they had used AI to apply for a job. That figure describes application behavior. It tells an interviewer very little about how a particular candidate prepared an answer.
Write the rule when you write the question
Consider a fictional customer ticket about a duplicate charge. In the first exercise, hand the candidate the ticket and a one-page escalation policy. Ask which facts they would verify before promising a refund. Allow the policy as a reference and ask for the candidate's own reasoning. Score whether they identify the missing transaction details and avoid a premature promise.
In the second exercise, ask for a customer email. Supply the same approved AI tool to everyone who wants it, along with the same fictional data. Tell candidates they own the final answer. Then add one fact in a follow-up conversation. The second charge is still pending. Ask what they would change. A polished email might look impressive on its own. The revision shows whether the candidate understands the advice they are sending.
Give interviewers the same instructions
Record permitted tools, required disclosures, and scoring criteria in the interview guide. In the email exercise, a candidate who writes unaided can earn full credit. Someone who uses AI can earn the same score by checking the transaction details, protecting customer information, and giving an accurate next step. If using the tool is itself a job requirement, tell candidates and assess that skill explicitly.
Put the policy in the invitation, then repeat it at the start. By the time an interviewer is looking at a surprisingly fluent answer, the team should already know what evidence it will accept.
Candidate AI use FAQs
What should an interview invitation say about ChatGPT or an AI note-taker?
“Please feel free to use AI to prepare before the interview. During the live case, use the policy sheet we provide and answer in your own words. For the written exercise, you may use the AI tool we supply. Tell us briefly how you checked the final answer. Please ask before enabling a recording or transcription tool so we can explain the arrangements. Contact your recruiting coordinator privately if you need an accommodation.” Adapt the wording to the actual exercise and give the coordinator a working reply channel.
If employees use AI at work, should candidates be allowed to use it on the work sample?
Usually, yes, when the work sample tests a task employees perform with AI. Give applicants comparable access, a clear time limit, and fictional materials. In the support example, score the accuracy of the response, the handling of uncertainty, and the follow-up promised to the customer. Add an unaided segment only when you can name the job decision it represents, such as recognizing a billing escalation while a writing tool is unavailable.
What should a recruiter do if they suspect a candidate used AI against the instructions?
Check what the invitation allowed, then ask the candidate to walk through their work before making a decision. If the instructions were ambiguous, clarify them and offer a comparable opportunity to demonstrate the skill. If they were clear, ask a neutral follow-up such as “Walk me through how you reached that answer and which resources you used.” Record the response and apply the same review process used for comparable cases. Polished language or an automated flag alone is too little evidence to conclude the applicant broke a rule.
FROM THE TALENT SIGNAL NEWS ARCHIVE
As Interviews Evolve Under Real-Time AI, Assessments And Work Sessions Carry More Weight




